This week Colten and Joshua are asking an uncomfortable question: what happened to "love your enemy"?Starting with clips from David French and some viral church moments, we trace how American Christianity drifted from its roots into something tangled up with fear, nationalism, and an us-versus-them mentality. We get into church history, Christian nationalism, immigration, nonviolence—and why so many believers today hold positions that seem hard to square with what Jesus actually taught.

We're also wrestling with some bigger questions: Has political identity quietly replaced faith identity? How does being in power (or losing it) change what people believe? And when everyone calls themselves "Christian," does the word even mean anything anymore?